Saturday, January 31, 2009

Audio Switch- A Failure story


Ver 0.1

Ver 0.1.1


As I'm a music freak, I have different music on different machines of mine(a desktop and a laptop), but I have only one 2.1 channel sound system which has to be shared by both machines, for which I need to switch between both by plugging and unplugging to a machine each time. This turned out be a huge problem as I have to reach out to the wires plug in/out. So I thought of making a manual Audio switch which would help me with this problem.
First I came up with the Version 0.1 of the switch.
Its summarized below:

Advantages:
  1. Easy to handle.
Disadvantages:
  1. It was very unstable because it wasn't mounted on a PCB.
  2. The sound output was not stereo mixed because of a design error.
  3. Was very noisy.
Then I came up with the second version named 0.1.1(since no change in design), which is summarized below:


Advantages:

  1. Was easier to handle than the old one.
  2. Noise was reduced to a great extent.
  3. Was stable as it was mounted on a PCB.
  4. Stereo quality sound output.
Disadvantages:

  1. Was prone to loose contacts and internal resistances of the extension chords.
  2. Instead of providing two separate channels, the switch was multiplexing both inputs, which turned out to be a Disaster!
In the end both versions didn't satisfy my needs and the Audio switch turned to be a big FAILURE!

If if you have any suggestions to improve this please do leave a comment.

1 comment:

Srichand Pendyala said...

if your sound sources are different, then you'll have the problem of unequal volumes. In that case, you'll want to add a 10k Log POT to each of the inputs, for some control.

Ideally, you want an op-amp with linear gain driving each input and a Logarithmic POT on the output...

Also, don't ever use a transistor for audio amplification! This is from experience!